Apparent Harmony
A Superficial Unity or a Deeper Truth?
The phrase “apparent harmony” suggests a seamless, peaceful coexistence, whether in philosophy, music, society, or even physics. But as we dig deeper, we often find that this harmony is superficial, masking underlying tensions, contradictions, or even chaos.
This theme is explored in Emily Herring’s analysis of time, where she argues against the conventional notion that time is composed of distinct present moments. Just as the present moment may be an illusion created by our perception, apparent harmony may be nothing more than a convenient fiction that hides deeper, more profound realities.
Is harmony truly what it seems, or is it a construct that helps us cope with complexity?
Emily Herring
Philosophy: The Hidden Discord Beneath Surface Agreement
Ancient philosophers like Heraclitus recognized that what appears harmonious may not reflect the deeper order of reality. He posited that "hidden harmony is stronger than apparent harmony," meaning that true order is often found in contradiction and opposition, not in smooth agreement.
Consider human relationships: a seemingly happy marriage may be held together by unspoken resentments. A well-functioning society may suppress dissent to maintain the illusion of unity. What looks like order is often a precarious balance of conflicting forces, an idea echoed in Taoist philosophy, where harmony arises not from uniformity, but from the dynamic interplay of opposites.
In the context of time, Emily Herring argues that the present moment is not a singular, well-defined point, but rather a conceptual illusion that emerges from our experience of continuity. Similarly, the harmony we perceive in life may be a construction of our minds rather than an objective reality.
Business Insight: Apparent harmony in a company—where everyone agrees in meetings—can be a warning sign, not a strength. True innovation thrives on creative tension, on voices willing to challenge the status quo.
Music: The Harmony We Imagine
In music, apparent harmony refers to the phenomenon where sequential notes create the impression of chords, even if they are not played simultaneously. This is because the human brain is wired to perceive structure, even in randomness.
Johann Sebastian Bach, for instance, often wrote melodies that implied harmonies through movement rather than direct chords. The listener “fills in” the missing notes, creating an illusion of harmony that exists more in perception than in reality.
Business Insight: Marketing often relies on apparent harmony, crafting a brand narrative that suggests coherence and trustworthiness, even when internal processes may be chaotic. The perception of a well-structured company can be more powerful than actual order.
Politics and Society: The Cost of Manufactured Unity
Apparent harmony is perhaps most dangerous in the political realm. Authoritarian regimes often achieve a form of harmony by silencing dissent. Everyone appears to agree, because disagreement is not an option.
In democracies, apparent harmony can also be a problem. Public relations strategies are often employed to project unity, even when factions within a party or nation are in deep conflict. The price of maintaining this illusion can be high, leading to instability when suppressed disagreements inevitably surface.
Business Insight: In corporate environments, excessive pursuit of apparent harmony can stifle innovation. Teams that never challenge each other risk stagnation. True harmony in business emerges from well-managed conflict, where differing perspectives are heard and synthesized into stronger strategies.
Time and Apparent Harmony: A False Continuity?
Emily Herring’s work on the nature of time aligns with the broader concept of apparent harmony. She critiques the idea that time is composed of discrete, present moments, arguing instead for a more fluid, interconnected experience.
This is strikingly similar to the way businesses and societies operate. We tend to view history as a series of distinct, harmonious periods—“the Golden Age,” “the Renaissance,” “the Post-War Boom”—when in reality, these were turbulent times filled with contradictions. What we remember as harmony was often just the smoothing effect of hindsight.
Business Insight: Companies often narrate their history in simplified, harmonious terms, "We started with a vision, we worked hard, and we succeeded." But the truth is always more complicated, filled with crises, failures, and pivots. The best leaders acknowledge this, rather than pretending that success is a linear, harmonious journey.
Strategic Mindfulness: Embracing the Hidden Harmony
The concept of strategic mindfulness provides a way forward. Instead of striving for surface-level harmony, businesses and leaders should embrace complexity, contradictions, and the natural tension that fuels growth.
Strategic mindfulness teaches that apparent harmony is an illusion, and true success comes from navigating the hidden currents beneath the surface. Just as a great jazz musician knows when to disrupt harmony to create something profound, a great leader understands that real alignment comes from engaging with, rather than suppressing, conflicting forces.
The Power of Seeing Beyond the Surface
Apparent harmony is seductive. It offers comfort and simplicity. But as Emily Herring, Heraclitus, and countless innovators have shown, true progress comes from looking beyond the illusion.
In life, business, and society, the real question is not whether harmony exists, but what it's hiding. The leaders, thinkers, and artists who recognize this—who see the hidden structures beneath the apparent harmony—are the ones who shape the future.
Your challenge: Where in your life or business are you mistaking apparent harmony for real alignment? What deeper truths might you be overlooking?
This is what I’m working on. Tell me what you think, I enjoy the conversation! Subscribe and follow the work in real time.
Thanks!
B
Apparent harmony is a mirage. In business, in society, in time itself, what looks seamless often hides contradiction. True growth comes from tension, not silence. Where are you mistaking agreement for alignment?
PS -