Beyond Hashtags

Why Feel-Good Activism Fails

Resistance isn’t about moral superiority or hashtags, it’s about results. Yet much of today’s activism is performative. Online campaigns, petitions, and marches often rally emotions without delivering the structural changes we need. It’s not that these actions lack value; it’s that they lack strategy.

We face entrenched systems of power designed to resist change. Bureaucracies don’t exist to empower people; they exist to maintain themselves. Legal frameworks are often engineered to protect those at the top. And here’s the hard truth: you can’t dismantle systems of control by following their rules.

Worse, resistance efforts are often undercut by a reliance on shame to drive action. You can’t shame people into change when they believe their actions are morally right. Shame doesn’t move the complacent, nor does it work against the powerful. If anything, it entrenches opposition.

So, how do we fight back? How do we build a movement that doesn’t just react but wins? The answer lies in moving past emotion-driven gestures to create systems, strategies, and structures designed to endure.

Pushing Past Complacency: The Role of Strategy

The greatest challenge isn’t external, it’s internal. Complacency is a barrier as strong as any law or policy. You can’t wait for people to feel outraged enough to act. You must build systems that make action inevitable.

Here’s how:

1. Build Parallel Infrastructure

Movements fail when they rely on the very systems they aim to disrupt. To succeed, resistance must create alternative systems that provide support, foster connection, and drive action.

• Local Hubs: Establish decentralized, autonomous hubs—both physical and digital—where communities can organize, share resources, and plan actions. Think of them as the resistance equivalent of a franchise: adaptable to local needs, but unified in purpose. These hubs should prioritize accessibility and inclusivity, providing a place for everyone, from activists to those just waking up to the need for change.
• Economic Independence: Starve entrenched systems by creating alternative economies. Co-operatives, mutual aid networks, and local currencies reduce dependence on centralized structures. These models not only foster self-reliance but demonstrate that resistance isn’t about destruction—it’s about building something better.
• Resource Networks: Build mutual aid systems that meet immediate needs—food, shelter, and healthcare—while creating bonds of solidarity. These networks aren’t charity; they’re the groundwork for a community that can survive without relying on external control.

2. Identify and Exploit Systemic Weak Points

Every system has vulnerabilities. The key to effective resistance is finding and targeting them.

• Map the System: Who funds the power structure? Who supports it? Where are the bottlenecks? Use tools and analysis to identify where pressure will have the greatest impact.
• Targeted Disruption: Broad, unfocused protests dilute energy. Instead, focus on strategic disruption. A small, co-ordinated group targeting a critical choke point—such as a supply chain or financial institution—can have an outsized impact. Resistance isn’t about being everywhere; it’s about being effective.

3. Leverage Strategic Partnerships

No movement succeeds in isolation. Partnerships amplify power.

• Cross-Issue Alliances: Build coalitions with groups fighting different battles but aligned in values. Environmentalists, labour organizers, and technologists may have distinct goals, but their strengths, when combined, can create exponential impact.
• Business Collaboration: Partner with ethical businesses. Entrepreneurs who prioritize transparency and equity can fund and support resistance efforts while demonstrating the viability of alternative models.

4. Master the Narrative

Power doesn’t just control resources; it controls the story. Effective resistance demands taking control of the narrative.

• Own Your Story: Your opponents are framing you as chaotic, irrelevant, or dangerous. Counter that with a compelling, unified narrative of transformation. Use storytelling to show what’s possible. Highlight victories—no matter how small—and emphasize the humanity and hope behind the movement.
• Move Beyond Emotional Appeals: Facts alone don’t change minds, and shaming people for complicity entrenches their beliefs. Instead, tell stories that make the stakes personal and the future tangible. Show—not tell—what’s at risk and what’s possible.

5. Weaponize Technology Wisely

Technology is a tool, not a solution. Used effectively, it can amplify resistance; used poorly, it can undermine it.

• Decentralized Communication: Avoid platforms vulnerable to censorship or surveillance. Use encrypted messaging, peer-to-peer networks, and open-source tools to stay secure and resilient.
• Data as a Weapon: Gather data to anticipate opposition, refine strategies, and track public sentiment. Borrow techniques from marketing and analytics to measure impact and adjust tactics in real-time.

6. Create a Leadership Pipeline

Movements don’t just need leaders, they need resilient, distributed leadership.

• Train for Resilience: Leadership isn’t born; it’s made. Develop programs to train leaders in crisis management, negotiation, and strategic planning.
• Shared Leadership Models: Avoid centralized leadership that can be easily targeted or corrupted. Build systems where leadership is shared and redundant, ensuring the movement can endure even if individuals are removed.

7. Commit to Long-Term Engagement

Resistance is not a moment, it’s a movement. Sustained engagement requires planning for the long haul.

• Sustainable Funding: Build financial independence through crowdfunding, subscription models, and ethical investments. Transparency in funding fosters trust and ensures accountability.
• Cultural Integration: Resistance must become a way of life. Integrate its principles into education, art, and community activities. Normalize dissent as a necessary and vital part of a healthy society.

A Vision for the Future

Imagine a resistance movement that doesn’t just react but builds. A movement that creates systems as it dismantles them. A world where power is distributed, not hoarded.

This isn’t a utopian dream. It’s a practical reality waiting to be built. But it requires more than hashtags or feel-good campaigns. It requires strategy, structure, and action.

So, ask yourself: What systems are you willing to build? What risks are you ready to take? Because resistance isn’t about moralizing—it’s about mobilizing.

1. Start Locally: Identify a single need in your community and begin building an alternative system to meet it.
2. Analyze and Act: Map a system of power and identify a vulnerability. Plan a targeted action to disrupt it.
3. Tell the Story: Share your vision of a better future. Inspire others to join and build with you.

Resistance isn’t theoretical. It’s practical. It’s actionable. And it’s waiting for you to begin.

Hashtags won’t save us. But strategy will.

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This is what I’m working on. Tell me what you think, I enjoy the conversation! Subscribe and follow the work in real time.

Thanks!

B

Hashtags won’t save us. You can’t dismantle systems of power with their own tools, or shame those who believe they’re morally right. Resistance needs strategy, not performance.

Build local hubs. Target weak points. Forge alliances. Take control of the narrative. Act.

It’s not about feeling good—it’s about winning.

PS -