The American Fantasy

The "American Dream" has long been a narrative of promise: an open invitation to success, wealth, and self-determination. But behind its seductive appeal lies a reality that has never quite aligned with its marketing. The Dream was never a universal truth, it has always been a carefully constructed myth, wielded to inspire productivity, docility, and the relentless pursuit of growth. Today, that myth is being sold harder than ever, even as its attainability diminishes with each passing decade.

What happens when the dream is less about prosperity, and more about control? What do we lose when we cling to a fantasy that sustains systems designed to benefit the few, at the expense of the many?

The Invention of the Dream: A Myth with Purpose

The American Dream is not a natural product of cultural evolution; it was engineered. In the early 20th century, it emerged as a deliberate narrative, amplified by advertising, mass media, and political rhetoric. James Truslow Adams coined the phrase in 1931, during the Great Depression, positioning it as a unifying ideal in a fractured nation. But even then, its reach was selective, limited to white men with access to capital, education, and opportunity.

From the start, the Dream served a dual purpose:

1. Inspiration for Labour: Workers were encouraged to toil harder, believing in the possibility of a better life just beyond the horizon.
2. Justification for Inequality: Those who failed to "make it" could be blamed for their lack of effort, rather than systemic barriers.

The Dream was never about equity or justice. It was a story told to fuel the economy, placate the masses, and mask the vast disparities baked into American society.

The Fantasy Intensifies: The Post-War Boom and Its Legacy

The mid-20th century brought the height of the Dream’s allure. The post-War economic boom, coupled with the rise of suburban living, painted a picture of prosperity accessible to all, if only they worked hard enough. Yet even in this golden era, the Dream excluded vast swaths of the population.

• Redlining and Housing Discrimination: Federal housing policies systematically excluded Black Americans and other minorities from homeownership, the cornerstone of middle-class wealth.
• Gender Inequality: Women were relegated to domestic roles, their economic contributions undervalued or outright dismissed.
• Exploitation of Immigrants: While the Dream beckoned immigrants with the promise of opportunity, they often found themselves trapped in low-paying, exploitative jobs.

The prosperity of the era was real for some, but the system depended on maintaining a myth that ignored the structural inequities enabling it.

The Dream Crumbles: The Modern Era of Disillusionment

Today, the American Dream is more unattainable than ever, but its myth is marketed with unprecedented ferocity. In an era of growing inequality, declining social mobility, and economic precarity, the Dream functions as a pacifier, an opiate for the masses.

• Wages vs. Costs: Over the past 50 years, wages for most Americans have stagnated while housing, education, and healthcare costs have soared. A college degree, once a ticket to upward mobility, is now a financial burden for millions.
• The Gig Economy: Sold as a liberating opportunity to "be your own boss," the gig economy has replaced stable jobs with precarious, low-wage work, eroding the safety nets once afforded by traditional employment.
• Wealth Disparity: The richest 1% have accumulated more wealth than the bottom 90% combined, yet the Dream persists as a narrative of individual achievement, distracting from systemic hoarding.

The Dream’s decline has not slowed its promotion. On the contrary, it’s being sold more aggressively than ever, from social media influencers flaunting their curated lifestyles to politicians promising a return to past prosperity. The more unattainable the Dream becomes, the more desperately we are encouraged to believe in it.

The Machinery of Myth: Why We Need to Believe

Why does the American Dream persist despite its obvious failings? The answer lies in its utility to the system.

• Perpetuating Productivity: The Dream incentivizes endless striving. Workers exhaust themselves in pursuit of a goal they are unlikely to reach, fueling the economy with their labour and spending.
• Deflecting Accountability: By framing success as a matter of personal effort, the Dream shields systemic inequalities from scrutiny. If you’re struggling, the problem is framed as yours, not the system’s.
• Sustaining Consumption: The Dream requires visible markers of success—homes, cars, vacations—which drive consumption. Even those who know the Dream is unattainable often go into debt to mimic its outward appearance.

The Dream keeps people in motion, chasing an ever-receding horizon. It’s a treadmill disguised as an escalator.

The Collateral Damage: A Society Strained by the Dream

The insistence on the American Dream comes at a steep cost. It fosters a culture of overwork, disconnection, and discontent:

• Mental Health Crises: The pressure to succeed has contributed to rising rates of anxiety, depression, and burnout.
• Erosion of Community: The Dream emphasizes individual achievement, often at the expense of collective well-being.
• Environmental Consequences: The constant push for growth and consumption depletes natural resources, and exacerbates climate change.

As the gap between the fantasy and reality widens, its toll becomes harder to ignore.

Breaking the Spell: Toward a New Vision of Prosperity

The American Dream cannot be salvaged in its current form—it is too tied to a system that prioritizes profit over people. But its failure opens the door to reimagine what prosperity could mean.

• Community over Individualism: A focus on shared well-being, rather than solitary success, can create stronger, more resilient societies.
• Equity over Growth: Policies that address systemic barriers—universal healthcare, affordable education, and fair wages—can create genuine opportunities.
• Sustainability over Consumption: Shifting away from endless material accumulation can protect the planet while fostering deeper fulfillment.

These shifts require more than individual effort; they demand systemic change and collective action.

Letting Go of the Dream to Build a Better Reality

The American Dream is not dying, it is being revealed. Its promises were always selective, its rewards conditional. The question now is not whether the Dream can be restored, but whether we have the courage to let it go.

What lies beyond the Dream may be uncertain, but it holds the potential for a more honest, equitable, and sustainable future. To get there, we must confront the myths that have sustained the system and commit to creating new stories—stories that reflect not just who we are, but who we aspire to be.

It’s time to wake up from the American Fantasy and begin the real work of building a better world.

What does the American Dream mean to you? Can we build a new vision of success together? Share your thoughts.

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This is what I’m working on. Tell me what you think, I enjoy the conversation! Subscribe and follow the work in real time.

Thanks!

B

The American Dream was never real, it’s a myth sold to keep us working, consuming, and hoping. The harder it gets to achieve, the more it’s marketed. It’s not about success; it’s about control. Time to wake up and build something real.

PS -