The Legacy Dilemma

There’s a certain romance to legacy businesses. They carry history, community goodwill, and family pride. But what happens when those same qualities become their undoing?

This story isn’t just about a business, it’s about the people behind it. Their hopes, their mistakes, and the moment they must decide between salvaging what’s left, or letting everything fall apart.

A Legacy Under Siege

Two years ago, a struggling business owner called me for help.

Her business—a 40-year-old legacy in a thriving market—had been the pride of her father, and a cornerstone of her community. She’d purchased it a couple of years previously, after a prospective buyer threatened to rebrand, determined to keep the family name alive.

* Really, her father had agreed to sell the business then, she heard they were going to change the name, so she bought it.

But this isn’t a tale of triumph.

She wasn’t prepared.

By trade, she was an accountant, meticulous with numbers but lacking the vision and leadership skills to run an enterprise. Her decision to buy the business was emotional, driven by pride and a desire to prove herself, not strategic foresight.

When I assessed the business two years ago, I didn’t mince words. “If nothing changes, you’ll be out of business in three years.”

She didn’t hire me.

She didn’t make any changes.

She didn’t make it three years.

Now, profits have plummeted, the team has dissolved, and competitors are circling. She’s finally back, asking for advice. But the clock is ticking, and her options are limited.

The People and the Pain

Let me paint the picture more vividly:

• The Owner: A former accountant thrust into leadership by circumstance, not capability. Her emotional attachment to the business blinds her to its flaws. She doesn’t want to be seen as a failure—by her community, by her father, or by herself. She understands hard work. That’s not business.
• The Workforce: Once a loyal team, now scattered. Most of the original staff have left for competitors, taking institutional knowledge and customer relationships with them.
• The Competitors: Growing, aggressive, and dominating the market. One even made a $7M buyout offer—generous given the business’s current state. She declined and countered at $8M, a number rooted in pride, not reality.

The business is hemorrhaging value. Profits have dropped from $1.6M to $400K in just three years. Customers are fleeing, operations are disorganized, and morale is non-existent. Competitors have grown 5-12% in the same period.

And yet, even in this chaos, there’s a chance to salvage something meaningful—if she’s willing to let go of her pride and make hard decisions.

Three Paths Forward

Every business crisis boils down to choices. For her, the options are stark:

1. The Fire Sale

• What It Means: Accept a likely reduced offer, liquidate, and walk away.
• The Emotional Cost: Publicly, this will feel like failure. Privately, it’s an admission that she couldn’t make it work.
• The Upside: Immediate financial relief and freedom from the daily stress of running a collapsing business.
• The Downside: The family name could disappear, and the employees and customers left behind will feel abandoned.

2. Rebuild Alone

• What It Means: Double down, take control, and fight to turn the business around.
• The Emotional Cost: Exhaustion. She’s already overwhelmed and lacks the experience and objectivity needed for a turnaround.
• The Upside: If she succeeds (and that’s a big “if”), she could preserve both the family legacy and her pride.
• The Downside: This path is riddled with risk. One wrong move could drive the business into complete insolvency, leaving nothing to sell.

3. The Proconsul Path: Stability, Growth, and a Thoughtful Transition

• What It Means: Commit to a strategic process designed to stabilize the business, rebuild its foundation, and transition it thoughtfully—either through a structured sale or to new leadership.
• The Emotional Cost: Requires humility. She must acknowledge that her strengths lie elsewhere and allow experienced professionals to take the reins.
• The Upside: Preserves the family name, maximizes the business’s value, and provides a roadmap for long-term success—even if she’s no longer at the helm.
• The Downside: It’s not a quick fix. This path demands time, investment, and collaboration.

The Proconsul Process: A Compassionate but Firm Roadmap

1. Stabilization: Stop the Bleeding

• Leadership Reset: Hire an experienced General Manager to stabilize operations and restore employee trust.
• Customer Reconnection: Launch targeted campaigns to win back customers with clear commitments to quality and service.
• Operational Efficiency: Modernize workflows with customer relationship management tools and better internal processes​.

2. Cultural Healing: Rebuilding Trust

• Employee Engagement: Offer incentives for key staff to stay through the transition. Address grievances through feedback systems, and take visible corrective actions.
• Owner Development: Enroll her in leadership coaching to enhance communication skills and emotional intelligence​.

3. Growth: Build a Stronger Business

• Market Expansion: Introduce new offerings aligned with customer needs and trends.
• Strategic Marketing: Rebrand—not to erase the past but to signal a new era of professionalism and growth​.

4. Transition: Plan for the Future

• Strategic Sale: Position the business as a revitalized asset, attracting higher offers than the original $7M.
• Legacy Preservation: Structure the sale to include the family name or establish the owner as a community ambassador, ensuring her continued presence without operational involvement​.

The Emotional Layer: Compassion Meets Frustration

Here’s the hard truth: she’s not equipped to be an owner. And that’s okay.

Not everyone is built for leadership. Her strengths lie in precision, order, and analysis—not in the messy, unpredictable art of managing people and growing a business. But pride has kept her from admitting that, and it’s costing her everything.

I feel compassion for her—she’s caught in a web of expectations, her own and others’. But I can’t deny the frustration either. She ignored good advice, made emotional decisions, and now stands on the precipice of failure.

* She is right where I said she would be, still asking for help to fix the same problems we knew were there two years ago, and she’s still not listening.

This is the paradox of Proconsul’s work: we see the potential in people and their businesses, even when they don’t see it themselves. We offer them a path forward, but they have to walk it.

I can show you what I see.

I can share how I would get it done.

You, have to choose to do it.

I have only three conditions to work with me.

1. Ask for help.
2. Listen to what I suggest.
3. Act on it.

It’s a big step to get to number 1.

Very few people actually listen to or read what I share.

It’s an exceptional person that will ask for help, listen to guidance, and then act on it. I will do everything in my power to support that person.

But it’s a choice I can’t make for them.

Reflection

This isn’t just her story. It’s the story of every leader who clings to control when they need to let go, every business owner whose pride clouds their judgment.

But there’s a better way. The Proconsul path isn’t about failure, it’s about transformation. It’s about taking what’s broken and building something sustainable, something lasting.

Are you facing tough decisions in your business? Let’s create a roadmap together. Whether you’re navigating growth, planning a transition, or trying to save a legacy, Proconsul is here to guide you—with compassion, clarity, and an unwavering commitment to your success.

Take the first step toward stability and growth.

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This is what I’m working on. Tell me what you think, I enjoy the conversation! Subscribe and follow the work in real time.

Thanks!

B

Legacy isn’t what you hold onto, it’s what you build to outlast you. Don’t let pride blind you to hard truths. A failing business doesn’t mean you’ve failed, but refusing to act might. Stability, growth, or exit… choose wisely.

PS -